‘Organists who have struggled with the three independent lines will marvel at Herrick's fluency … Recording quality is superb, the recently built Metzler organ a delight to the ear, and the documentation exemplary. Outstanding’ (BBC Music Magazine Top 1000 CDs Guide)
‘The most persuasive, vivid and compelling performances ever of these sonatas. Herrick's bubbly playing, not to mention Hyperion's superb recording, bring Bach vividly to life’ (Gramophone)
‘This stunning disc … immense fun, brimming over with real affection for the music. A disc of rare beauty and a gem in any collection’ (The Good CD Guide)
‘Outstanding. The whole package is quite superb’ (Hi-Fi News)
‘Fresh … colourful … beguiling … Inspired and imaginative, the whole experience is fun’ (The Musical Times)
'Una delle migliorii esecuzioni bachiane di tutti I tempi' (Musica, Italy)
