Please wait...

Hyperion Records

Click cover art to view larger version
Death as an Avenger (1851) by Alfred Rethel (1816-1859)
Track(s) taken from CDA67401/2
Recording details: July 1998
Budapest Studios of Hungarian Radio, Hungary
Produced by Tryggvi Tryggvason
Engineered by Tryggvi Tryggvason
Release date: November 1998
Total duration: 13 minutes 56 seconds

Concerto in E flat, S125a Op posth.
circa 1836/9; score prepared from manuscript sources by Jay Rosenblatt; further preparation and performing version of solo part by Leslie Howard

Andante  [4'02]

Introduction  EnglishFrançaisDeutsch
For the complete history of the posthumously published Concerto in E flat (sometimes unhelpfully referred to as ‘Concerto No 3’) the reader is recommended to Jay Rosenblatt’s excellent introduction to the published score (Editio Musica Budapest) in which he describes the considerable degree of detective work which he was obliged to undertake to reassemble this composition which had remained unknown for well over a century, a feat he accomplished with much flair and wisdom. Parts of the manuscript score are located in Moscow, Weimar and Nuremberg (where a folio of this work was miscatalogued for many years, thought to be discarded material from the Concerto No 1), and a copyist’s score is held in Weimar. The piano part is not actually completed. Letting Mr Rosenblatt illuminate us:

For the first draft, Liszt wrote out a piano score on two staves with plenty of blank space above and below for revisions. The next stage was an orchestral score without a piano part, and the piano score from the first stage was modified such that it served as the missing piano part to the orchestral score. For substantial revisions, Liszt cancelled the passage in both scores, and wrote out separate pages with all parts, piano and orchestra. The manuscripts were then given to a copyist, who integrated them and returned a fair copy to Liszt for final corrections, revisions, and the addition of articulation and dynamic markings. This procedure can be seen in the various surviving scores for the first and second piano concertos.

(Clearly, then, this explains the many scores of much of Liszt’s concertante and orchestral œuvre found in copyists’ hands, and gives the lie to the notion that Raff, Conradi, or any other amanuensis, was in any way responsible for Liszt’s orchestration.) In 1836 Liszt asked his mother to send him copies of some of his earliest published compositions: two sets of Variations, the Allegro & Rondo di bravura and the early set of Études (Opp 1, 2, 4 and 6—all of which are recorded in Volume 26). These last became the basis of the Douze Grandes études, and three of the other works provided material for the present concerto. Liszt spoke of having three concertos ready at the end of 1839. Two are those we know well, although not nearly in their final form, the other is this concerto, which Liszt never revised for publication and performance. There remain passages where the original short score piano part has been crossed out, or where it does not fit the final orchestral score, or where it is left doubling the orchestra, and a discreet amount of reorganizing of the texture seemed necessary to the present writer (whose article on the subject and facsimile of all the suggested text can be consulted in the Liszt Society Journal, 1993) in order to extract a suitable piano part from its orchestral surroundings.

The concerto is in a form dear to Liszt: a concert Allegro with interpolated slow movement and a coda in the character of a scherzo, with many recitative-like musings at the structural divisions. The opening presents the principal theme—derived from the Allegro di bravura, but in the guise of an introduction with cadenzas. The reappearance of the orchestra indicates the movement proper, and a triplet motif borrowed from the Rondo di bravura leads to the full statement of the principal theme in E flat minor (and despite the variety of key signatures, this concerto really is in E flat minor rather than major). The music makes its way to D major and a martial second theme which never reappears, and thence to a development section which breaks off with a short cadenza and leads to the slow movement in G flat major, whose theme is adapted from the one which Liszt had first composed for his Opus 1 Variations. The development resumes in F sharp minor and the shortened recapitulation of the first theme follows. The coda, finally in E flat major, is a scherzando transformation of the first theme with interpolated references to the slow movement.

from notes by Leslie Howard © 1998

Other albums featuring this work
'Liszt: Complete Piano Music' (CDS44501/98)
Liszt: Complete Piano Music
MP3 £160.00FLAC £160.00ALAC £160.00Buy by post £200.00 CDS44501/98  99CDs Boxed set + book (at a special price)  
   English   Français   Deutsch