Please wait...

Hyperion Records

Click cover art to view larger version
Moon Rising Over the Sea (1821) by Caspar David Friedrich (1774-1840)
Hermitage, St Petersburg, Russia / Bridgeman Art Library, London
Track(s) taken from CDA67622
Recording details: April 2007
Auditorio Stelio Molo, Lugano, Switzerland
Produced by Ben Connellan
Engineered by Michael Rast
Release date: March 2008
Total duration: 33 minutes 23 seconds

'Spohr the symphonist repays the attention this disc merits; his programmatic fourth symphony features a slow finale that set a precedent for Tchaikovsky and Mahler, while Shelley and his fine Italian players capture the expressive power of the turbulent fifth' (The Observer)

'Shelley's triumphant achievement … expert engineering and highly informative notes complete a handsome presentation that suggests this will be a landmark cycle in the burgeoning recorded legacy of Louis Spohr' (American Record Guide)

'The Fifth Symphony … carries a weightier burden of grief in the wake of some personal losses … especially in the Larghetto, a dark movement beautifully scored with low strings and sombre brass … Howard Shelley and his orchestra give it a fresh and vivid performance' (International Record Review)

'Here is a follow-up to the recording of Louis Spohr's first two symphonies that I praised last October … there's a lovely anticipation of 'Forest Murmurs' from Wagner's Siegfried; similarly, the Larghetto of Symphony No 5 might put you in mind of Mendelssohn's Scottish Symphony. Shelley gets both delicacy and passion from the excellent orchestra' (Classic FM Magazine)

'[Shelley] exhibits a keen understanding of Spohr’s music and also has the ability to effectively communicate this to his orchestra … playing is clean, clear and crisp—with tempos that allow the music to unfold comfortably. The aural perspective mimics concert hall realism, but it also allows for Spohr’s lovely wind coloration too. The result is another Hyperion release that offers us further insight into the process of Spohr’s symphonic development' (Fanfare, USA)

Symphony No 5 in C minor, Op 102
completed 27 September 1837; commissioned by the Viennese Concerts Spirituels; first performed in Vienna on 1 March 1838

Larghetto  [6'25]
Scherzo  [4'08]
Presto  [10'38]

Introduction  EnglishFrançaisDeutsch
It was the success of Die Weihe der Töne in Vienna in 1834 and 1836 which led to the composition of Spohr’s next symphony, commissioned by the Viennese Concerts Spirituels. The Symphony No 5 in C minor Op 102 was completed on 27 September 1837 and received its premiere in Vienna on 1 March 1838. By this time, following the death of his wife in 1834, Spohr had remarried. His new wife, Marianne, was twenty-three years younger than her husband and was the sister of the composer’s late friend Carl Pfeiffer. Although Marianne provided Spohr with the domestic stability he desired and proved a loyal companion, the composer never really recovered from the death of Dorette and his feelings of loss were intensified in the summer of 1838 when their youngest daughter, Therese, died shortly before her twentieth birthday.

In the fifth symphony Spohr seems to have poured out the pent-up emotions of his losses in the 1830s with real expressive power. For the first movement he revised a fantasy-overture he had written in November 1836 on Ernst Raupach’s adaptation of the mythical tragedy The Daughter of the Air by the Spanish dramatist Calderón (1600–1681) about the Assyrian princess Semiramis, though the composer did not assign any programme to the symphony. The work opens with a slow introduction in C major featuring a lyrical theme over a pedal point. All seems serene at first but gradually the music becomes more animated and then the full orchestra erupts with a powerful Allegro motif in C minor. This is extended with considerable impetus before the mood relaxes somewhat for the second subject in E flat, but tension quickly returns until the development. Here an oboe brings back the lyrical theme from the slow introduction, but this period of repose is interrupted by development of the second subject. The lyrical theme tries again, this time on the violins in a relaxed G major with a pizzicato accompaniment, but soon an undertow of the Allegro material appears and the recapitulation bursts in. In the coda the mood is restless and uncertain, but finally brightens up to C major after seeming to head for a minor key conclusion.

The Larghetto in A flat major is one of Spohr’s finest slow movements. It is the heart of the symphony with an elevated, aspiring theme leading to instrumental ‘sighs’ as three trombones add gravity to the orchestration. A more active contrasting section works with a dotted fugato figure, and when the main material returns to build up to the movement’s climax this fugato phrase is incorporated into the texture, and is then recalled by the horns to permeate the coda.

A horn call opens the C major Scherzo which works with a short motif full of energy, and is contrasted with a trio in D flat major which is dominated by delicate interweaving of the wind instruments while the strings play pizzicato, before the coda combines both scherzo and trio. This Scherzo was encored at the Vienna premiere.

The Presto finale brings a return of conflict and the key of C minor in a stormy, contrapuntal outpouring which drives forward without let-up, while trombones in their highest register emphasize the drama. The lyrical theme from the first movement returns to do duty as the second subject with its rhythm adapted to the restless energy of the finale. This lyrical theme starts the coda in A flat major, but the mood of restlessness is not really resolved despite a modulation back to C major as the final chords are punched out.

from notes by Keith Warsop © 2008
Chairman, Spohr Society of Great Britain

   English   Français   Deutsch