The Daily Telegraph

Here is a Lucia to match Callas or Sutherland. Natalie Dessay's light soprano gives a vivid impression of Lucia's vulnerable personality. The Mad Scene is enthralling. Piotr Beczala is a gloriously virile Edgardo, and the Italian style of the Russian cast more than acceptable. With Valery Gergiev a surprisingly sensitive conductor, this is a top-rank recording of a marvellous opera.