‘The Scherzo shows the Hallé winds and brass to excellent effect and I was warmed by Elder's well-aimed use of string portamentos in the 'Cavatina' … I would recommend it unreservedly’ (Gramophone) BBC Music Magazine ‘Vaughan Williams’s outwardly serene Symphony No 5 is a difficult work to get right … which is why Sir Mark Elder’s recording does succeed; he manages to inject a hint of drama into the static op ...