Hyperion Records

String Quartet in G minor, L91
1893; Op 10; first performed by the Ysaÿe Quartet on 29 December 1893

'Ravel & Debussy: String Quartets' (CDA67759)
Ravel & Debussy: String Quartets
'Debussy & Ravel: String Quartets' (CDH88018)
Debussy & Ravel: String Quartets
CDH88018  Helios (Hyperion's budget label) — Rights no longer controlled by Hyperion  
Movement 1: Animé et très décidé
Track 1 on CDA67759 [6'19]
Track 1 on CDH88018 [6'54] Helios (Hyperion's budget label) — Rights no longer controlled by Hyperion
Movement 2: Assez vif et bien rythmé
Track 2 on CDA67759 [3'54]
Track 2 on CDH88018 [4'01] Helios (Hyperion's budget label) — Rights no longer controlled by Hyperion
Movement 3: Andantino, doucement expressif
Track 3 on CDA67759 [7'36]
Track 3 on CDH88018 [8'41] Helios (Hyperion's budget label) — Rights no longer controlled by Hyperion
Movement 4: Très modéré
Track 4 on CDA67759 [6'54]
Track 4 on CDH88018 [7'29] Helios (Hyperion's budget label) — Rights no longer controlled by Hyperion

String Quartet in G minor, L91
After the Franco-Prussian War and the horrors of the Commune, there was a determination to show that France was not only free of the invader, but also once again a functioning entity. The foundation of the Société Nationale de Musique in 1871, with the motto ‘Ars Gallica’, was to provide an invaluable platform for the works of younger French composers. But, for whatever reason, amid the welter of French violin sonatas, piano trios and piano quartets written in the 1870s and ’80s, string quartets were in relatively short supply, certainly from the major composers. Possibly intimidated by the ghost of Beethoven, César Franck and Fauré did not venture to write one until they were sixty-eight and seventy-nine respectively (in 1890 and 1924) and for Debussy, and later Ravel, to enter this domain around the age of thirty was to court charges of presumption.

Before the first performance of the Debussy Quartet by the Ysaÿe Quartet on 29 December 1893, audiences at the Société Nationale had already heard Debussy’s cantata La damoiselle élue, of which one critic wrote prophetically ‘this subcutaneous injection may possibly produce dangerous eruptions among the young composers of the near future’. The Quartet too was to have a decisive influence, notably on Ravel. Some of the immediate responses from the critics were enthusiastic, but not those of Chausson, with whom Debussy was very friendly at the time. It is clear from a letter Debussy wrote to him on 5 February 1894 that Chausson liked things in the work which Debussy would rather had remained undetected, and that he found Debussy’s forms lacking in decorum: ‘I’ll write another one which will be for you, and I’ll try and bring some nobility to my forms’, responded Debussy, with just a hint of acid.

We can only guess as to exactly which parts of the Quartet Chausson objected to: the scherzo perhaps, full of flying pizzicati, and very probably a reminiscence of the gamelan he had heard at the 1889 Exposition; or indeed the very opening of the first movement, where an initially impassioned modal statement simply runs out of steam by the twelfth bar, to be succeeded by an apparently unrelated theme in a quite different mood. Chausson’s view was that Debussy did not roll up his sleeves and really get to work on his material—a similar response to that from Vincent d’Indy, who later told Georges Auric that both the Debussy and Ravel quartets were no more than ‘jolis morceaux pour quatuor à cordes’.

But then Debussy always resisted orthodox ‘development’ of his ideas, much preferring to exercise a looser ‘fantaisie’ through free variation, as in the transformations of the Quartet’s opening theme, which itself owes something to Grieg’s first String Quartet, also in G minor. To label these transformations ‘cyclic’, in the manner of Franck, is to miss something of the Debussyan essence. The theme does not, for example, culminate in any grand peroration like the one in Franck’s Symphonic Variations, unkindly dubbed by Alfred Cortot ‘l’embourgeoisement du thème’. Debussy’s approach is nearer to Monet’s in recording the variations of light on the façade of Rouen Cathedral. Contemporary critics noted that in the slow movement the Russian influence was alive and well, and it could be that this whiff of exoticism struck Chausson as unpatriotic.

from notes by Roger Nichols © 2010

Track-specific metadata
Click track numbers opposite to select

Details for CDA67759 track 4
Très modéré
Recording date
3 March 2009
Recording venue
Potton Hall, Dunwich, Suffolk, United Kingdom
Recording producer
Jeremy Hayes
Recording engineer
Ben Connellan
Hyperion usage
  1. Ravel & Debussy: String Quartets (CDA67759)
    Disc 1 Track 4
    Release date: January 2010
   English   Français   Deutsch